Inside the First Choice Auto Mall Inc office and customer lounge

Family-run · Rochester, NY · Since 2026

Honest used cars, ready for their next chapter.

Every vehicle on our lot is hand-inspected and priced with a straight face. No games, no pressure — just a good car and a fair number.

40+
Cars sold
4.9
Avg rating
6
Months local

Fresh on the lot

A few favorites our customers are loving this week.

2025Storm Cloud · Black interior3 photos

Toyota Grand Highlander LE AWD

7,664 mi · Automatic · Gasoline

2025Steel Graphite · Black interior3 photos

Hyundai Palisade SEL Premium AWD

23,500 mi · Automatic · Gasoline

2026Varesine Blue · Black interior3 photos

Land Rover Range Rover Velar P250 Dynamic SE AWD

4,013 mi · Automatic · Gasoline

2022Red · Black interior3 photos

RAM 1500 Big Horn

66,410 mi · Automatic · Gasoline

Why folks keep coming back

We're a small local lot, not a big box. That means we know our cars, price them fair, and stand behind every sale.

01

120-point inspection

Every car checked top to bottom before it hits the lot.

02

Fair, honest pricing

No games, no pressure, no hidden fees at the desk.

03

Local & accountable

We're your neighbors — and we mean it.

Sell to us

Get a fair, honest offer in under 24 hours.

Send us your car's details. We'll inspect it in daylight and give you a real number — not a lowball.

Get my offer
First Choice Auto Mall Inc dealership in Rochester, NY

Come see it

The lot is open till six.

Address · 42 Independence Street, Rochester, NY

Phone · (833) 334-7787

Hours · Mon–Sat 9am–6pm, closed Sundays

Call or book a visit
First Choice Auto Mall Inc building exterior in Rochester, NY